The Luis Castillo Rockies trade is the right call, and I’ll say that while holding my nose: the White Sox just handed Colorado a pitcher they gave up real assets for in August, and they got something back for him anyway.
Colorado takes Castillo and Davis Martin for lefty Sean Sullivan and minor-league catcher Douglas Veliz. The Rockies absorb Castillo’s contract, which is the whole point of the deal for Chicago.
The Chicago White Sox unload starter Luis Castillo and his $20 million salary while including Davis Martin to the Colorado Rockies for Sean Sullivan and a prospect.
The Castillo trade turned out to be a disaster and the White Sox wasted no time getting rid of their mistake.…— Bob Nightengale (@BNightengale) November 20, 2026
Castillo put up an 8.42 ERA over nine appearances in Chicago and lost his rotation spot. That is a short and ugly tenure for a guy they traded for at the deadline.
Credit where it’s due, though. Cutting the loss fast beats paying it off in slow motion. Plenty of front offices would have kept running him out there to avoid admitting anything.
Now the part nobody on the South Side wants to hear.
Martin was in the deal, and he’s a real arm. Fox has him at 9-4 with a 3.41 ERA in the first half for the White Sox. Chicago just sent two starters out the door, days after reports of a three-year, $52.5 million deal with Dustin May (still pending a physical when it was reported). That leaves May and a lot of open innings.
Getting rid of Castillo clears the books. It does not fill a rotation. The savings only matter if they turn into an actual starter, and not another pitcher on a deal that looks fine in November and grim by June.
My guess is that Martin’s second half is why Chicago was comfortable moving him. That’s my read, not something I can back with a number. Veliz is a 17-year-old catcher out of Venezuela and Fox calls him “more of a dart throw,” so nobody’s calling this a haul.
So far the White Sox have only done the first half of the plan.